Eyes have been a learning process for me. It's hard to get eyes that don't look weird or creepy, but are still representative of a more realistic style.
Not every eye style will work for every project. Here are the different representations of eye techniques:
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiMLOzngtDjCmSlwYryfDs8kxgP4K-wCYa0r1VkPQKslh8BUVHn3urJqL-8QYNo50OJaiFn9fxC4BULicqeX_Uj4O1WtMzuX-EmJvV9-0OLtJa_1n2mpamwOyw4dlXMF75v8TNkryi-k-Ca/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+9.00.08+AM.png)
This is simply a French knot on top of the felt face.
This works fine for projects like this--these Firefly finger puppets don't need accurate eyes, just a suggestion of them.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEixYx6E0Qgx5Ds2KyhsXlL33SRG9iAF_oer4-sZo0nSvu9UhGF3yaGa0ks9Agu7uNBUrtua690t9Q2FLr_uG4SaDDXcAlT3SXbERPOEb93j0cWj4IHtfaNqThmYs_U-IH5buiuXwfTrdTTn/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+8.58.06+AM.png)
Here, Leia is meant to be more cartoonish, so I simply cut out very tiny rounds of felt and glued them on the face piece.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjb2ZwdNFnleD3o4V-ZVLEbXI68-NzTtY1peETmLMLHRjAjYPmQ_SFzPiwAf-w_5DXLQrnFMil8TtKfTxHbDuz0Q03ANdxRKyLOs9WolBe0drpKLW_xdZiFeTLf7206ZyLfnKMAwKr2Nk1d/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+8.59.55+AM.png)
Cartoony characters in general are a bit easier. It's easy to layer their eyes with different color felt components. They don't need to look flat or inset, because a pop-eyed effect doesn't take away from the overall look (or, in some cases, is consistent with the character).
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhjo9lqd4YJehsfkcelBxESQZvBzz4CVZ23jA0zaHzeok39FONjWiA7qfFaN9pQvFZcRrg7Rwdl7PsnVRQB83vu5CrsyYW_ZPDnuiLOzZ7-OqRpX3leX4KVOHxKHc4lZz-UzNe_cAE5zCZp/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+9.00.46+AM.png)
This is a simple backstitch over the felt layer using the full strand of embroidery thread. I find it a bit bulky.
Julia also has a face under this face. Because the first eyes just did NOT work out and I had to try again.
These two are examples of the same backstitch technique, but using different strand thicknesses. The Handmaid is has 3 strands of thread from the 6-strand original, and Rosie the Riveter has 2 strands of thread and some very fine eyelash detailing.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhg6mTvQ6enVGmV35jyIKL-YvUR0uoYRCywwGi1ovrkWwXMpF8CcFWFL9N9gztqcIuR1BVyrFRmcYetN3xb10qu1fekuCugV2X14P1uJOnJxshoPndcsKynNdiutSpkEDzmJ1fnaQN6CEgt/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+9.00.22+AM.png)
Bob Ross and Captain Picard are examples of stitching the eye shape detailing and then doing a French knot pupil. In Bob's case, he doesn't have any additional eye fill, where in Picard's case, the whites of his eyes are stitched in. I do not prefer this technique, and if I re-did these I would use the next technique.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjwD8lQTub06qh_RcyhBaNSDBn5Vb7cwVlKjEPup36ifQ_QI59JjpwRl1UtE0akhi_yYf6z-Q8b5TFtDVDEp25Ycj3T7cnOTTyU0yLiTKk40e5ZJ_58cEYfBsyo2JTSoQx2j2moTqNvhx5r/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+8.59.45+AM.png)
Cut-out eyes are tricky but the effect is worth it. Here, you cut out the eyes in the top layer of felt and then insert a small piece of felt for the pupil. This took some time to learn.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhvuGA0PxEeVW5fp-RIsjStrMfxLkZctP-A5oiF8LckMhJnNObJHSlpWZiw5XBbDvGj_WediuMnbnifRu4htO7qtY9B4ClS82PWYqmf7VgbEoGO0MK-c-enTcpubeJN83eoTGB8yUk7N4Yw/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+9.01.16+AM.png)
Ruth Bader Ginsberg was my first experiment in this technique. Because she has dark eyes and light skin, overall this works.
With Michelle Obama, I thought I'd try an inset French knot. So I cut out the eye holes, but I filled them in with a French knot instead of felt. This is not a bad technique, but the felt pieces were easier for me.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiR30Ij8w1Eh7tx6nCsksndBTsvQ2eCs9NZn4_KdnqgA0SiqZJ5E45-oVwgcnVWc1gId4S5Ft7hPZ80nhTqrmwe44H80GSbi3BBJN1e48h3q94Je3mTBLlD2sSmdqbkInsuUyttpxXyxDlu/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+8.58.56+AM.png)
The first attempt didn't include whites which, in my opinion, is not a great look. I added a tiny bit of white felt filler (without gluing in), and I think it looks much better that way.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEieJSRMGuBXd4kQf9uuE_UynA_YYCK4sCosGcWl5i2-gdzeVVJkYOdOAWQJhA23aComiDpK18xJdsW8H_bF7s-G0see7PZa_7f0DGC5uIGcZO6WNJwAE0JRbaHu56UmlHUGeDsKXYPwfeAn/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+8.59.28+AM.png)
Filler also improved RuPaul's eyes. I don't glue in the white filler, I just tuck it in the eye hole. It should stay with normal use.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiVfM4AYzrTsoN6a_HteSUX33n32HIAkBtbDe30oFALQ969dlk4mlfG4vhSuW932BLVLkb5x8qchQGRMzkQCqwV_S21yayXXITFvtAqNTBuA4jlRXx-1x-P4GZLfOzQAVGloICL_QPvQ9q6/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+9.01.07+AM.png)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjSPp_tEDXVwvuZ5S7-GBDhv_ZySIg38rVPRsHx3SuE5JfZiszK-0edUs7sRCNck6vfRxT8PyaJ5BvyCnDfM-U_NNDrDrLKjd4UmRmkiD5cQAYur5o1mVvfV_igz7PVKkhiJPseGlm-ZsCu/s200/Screen+Shot+2017-01-04+at+9.01.03+AM.png)
Princess Leia and Carrie Fisher, like RBG, didn't seem greatly improved with eye white filler. So I left them as-is--cut-out eyes with felt pieces glued in the center.
Of course, if this is all too complex, you can always take the easy way out...
And just make weeping angels.